Real Estate in New Tecumseth

New Tecumseth is made up of three communities: Alliston, Beeton and Tottenham. If you are buying or selling a home anywhere in the town, you want someone who works here every day. Jamie McGinty is a Broker with RE/MAX Hallmark Chay Realty Inc., Brokerage, based at 20 Victoria St. W in Alliston, and he has sold 1,024 homes. He lives in Beeton and works across all three communities.

The Town of New Tecumseth

New Tecumseth is a town in Simcoe County. Alliston is home to Jamie's office. Beeton is a quiet, small town community where Jamie lives. Tottenham is the most southern community in Simcoe County, north of Highway 9 and 20 kilometres west of Highway 400. Highway 400 and Highway 9 link the town to Barrie and the GTA, which makes all three communities practical for commuters while keeping the small town feel.

Homes here range from detached houses on large lots to semis, backplits and condos. Alliston has the most choice, including the Briar Hill adult lifestyle community. Beeton and Tottenham offer quieter streets and larger lots, with Beeton close to Highways 400, 27, 50 and 9.

New Tecumseth Market Snapshot

Figures from the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board Market Watch, Simcoe County edition, September 2026. That is the latest month published as of November 5, 2026. October 2026 figures were not published yet.

Detached homes, September 2026:

39 detached homes sold

Average sale price: $853,341

Median sale price: $810,000

91 new listings, 178 active listings

Homes sold for 95% of list price on average

Average 44 days on market

Compared with October 2025, the detached average price was down 0.1 percent, from $854,401 to $853,341, and the median price was unchanged at $810,000. Note the interval: October 2025 to September 2026 is an 11-month interval, not a full year.

All home types, September 2026:

54 homes sold

Average sale price: $807,218

Median sale price: $767,500

129 new listings, 251 active listings

5.2 months of inventory

Homes sold for 96% of list price on average

Average 53 days on market

All home types prices rose over the same 11-month interval. The average was $773,215 in October 2025 and $807,218 in September 2026.

In plain terms, detached prices in New Tecumseth were essentially flat while the wider market moved up. Sellers should price on current comparable sales, not on last year's numbers. Buyers have more choice than they did a year ago, with 178 detached homes active in September 2026.

Your Local Realtor in New Tecumseth

Jamie McGinty has sold 1,024 homes. He is a Broker with RE/MAX Hallmark Chay Realty Inc., Brokerage, at 20 Victoria St. W, Alliston. He lives in Beeton, his office is in Alliston, and he lists and sells homes in all three New Tecumseth communities. When you call, you talk to Jamie directly.

Homes for Sale in New Tecumseth

Current listings, verified on jamiemcginty.com on November 5, 2026:

61 Stewart Ave, Alliston, $659,000

https://www.jamiemcginty.com/properties/61-stewart-ave-alliston

4 bed, 2 bath, 1,513 sq ft semi-detached backsplit on a 65 by 120 ft lot with a detached garage. MLS N14147406.

14 Douglas Dr, Alliston, $729,900

https://www.jamiemcginty.com/properties/14-douglas-dr

3 bed, 3 bath, 1,501 sq ft brick and stone bungalow on a 90 by 185 ft lot.

78 Sunset Blvd, Unit 305, Alliston, $359,900

https://www.jamiemcginty.com/properties/78-sunset-boulevard-unit-305

1+1 bed, 1 bath, 874 sq ft condo in the Briar Hill adult lifestyle community. MLS N14133634.

61 Carleton Trail, Beeton, $879,900

https://www.jamiemcginty.com/properties/61-carleton-trail

3 bed, 3.5 bath, 2,033 sq ft above grade, Devonleigh built Monterey model on a 40 by 100 ft lot. MLS N13833224.

96 Maple Ave W, Beeton, $729,900

https://www.jamiemcginty.com/properties/96-maple-ave-w

2 bed, 2 bath, 1,169 sq ft backsplit on a 50 by 150 ft lot. MLS N13630112.

See all current listings on the Properties page: https://www.jamiemcginty.com/properties

Thinking of Buying or Selling in New Tecumseth?

Call Jamie McGinty directly at 705-440-9440 or email jamie@jamiemcginty.com. For sellers, Jamie provides a market analysis based on recent comparable sales in your community, not a generic estimate.