Real Estate in Tottenham, Ontario

Tottenham is one of the three communities in the Town of New Tecumseth, along with Alliston and Beeton. If you are buying or selling a home in Tottenham, you want a realtor who knows the town and works here every day. Jamie McGinty is a Broker with RE/MAX Hallmark Chay Realty Inc., Brokerage, based at 20 Victoria St. W in Alliston, and he has sold 1,024 homes. His gym is the Tottenham Community Centre on Queen Street, so he is in Tottenham regularly.

The Community of Tottenham

Tottenham is part of the Town of New Tecumseth in Simcoe County. It is the most southern community in Simcoe County, located north of Highway 9 and 20 kilometres west of Highway 400. That location makes it a practical commuter community, with Highway 9 and Highway 400 linking it to the GTA in the south and Barrie in the north.

Tottenham had an estimated population of 9,609 in the 2021 census. Most shopping in town is found on Queen Street, around the corner of Queen Street and Mill Street. The Tottenham Community and Fitness Centre is one of the town's main recreation facilities.

Homes in Tottenham are mostly detached houses, many on good sized lots, with a quieter, small town feel than the larger centres to the north. It suits buyers who want space and a short drive to Highway 400 without giving up a real community.

Tottenham Market Snapshot

TRREB reports market figures by municipality, not by community, so there are no Tottenham-only figures published. The figures below are for the Town of New Tecumseth as a whole, which includes Tottenham, from the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board Market Watch, Simcoe County edition, September 2026. That is the latest month published as of November 5, 2026. October 2026 figures were not published yet.

Detached homes in New Tecumseth, September 2026:

39 detached homes sold

Average sale price: $853,341

Median sale price: $810,000

91 new listings, 178 active listings

Homes sold for 95% of list price on average

Average 44 days on market

Compared with October 2025, the detached average price was down 0.1 percent, from $854,401 to $853,341, and the median price was unchanged at $810,000. Note the interval: October 2025 to September 2026 is an 11-month interval, not a full year.

All home types in New Tecumseth, September 2026:

54 homes sold

Average sale price: $807,218

Median sale price: $767,500

129 new listings, 251 active listings

5.2 months of inventory

Homes sold for 96% of list price on average

Average 53 days on market

All home types prices rose over the same 11-month interval. The average was $773,215 in October 2025 and $807,218 in September 2026.

In plain terms, detached prices across New Tecumseth were essentially flat while the wider market moved up. For a Tottenham home, the right price still comes down to recent comparable sales in Tottenham itself, not the town-wide average. Ask Jamie for a market analysis based on Tottenham sales.

Your Local Realtor in Tottenham

Jamie McGinty has sold 1,024 homes. He is a Broker with RE/MAX Hallmark Chay Realty Inc., Brokerage, at 20 Victoria St. W, Alliston. He lives in Beeton, works across all three New Tecumseth communities, and trains at the Tottenham Community Centre on Queen Street. When you call, you talk to Jamie directly.

Homes for Sale in and Around Tottenham

No Tottenham-addressed listing of Jamie's was live on jamiemcginty.com when this draft was written on November 5, 2026, so no Tottenham listing is shown here. The closest current listings, in neighbouring Beeton, are:

61 Carleton Trail, Beeton, $879,900

https://www.jamiemcginty.com/properties/61-carleton-trail

3 bed, 3.5 bath, 2,033 sq ft above grade, Devonleigh built Monterey model on a 40 by 100 ft lot. MLS N13833224.

96 Maple Ave W, Beeton, $729,900

https://www.jamiemcginty.com/properties/96-maple-ave-w

2 bed, 2 bath, 1,169 sq ft backsplit on a 50 by 150 ft lot. MLS N13630112.

See all current listings on the Properties page: https://www.jamiemcginty.com/properties

See the New Tecumseth page for listings in Alliston and Beeton: https://www.jamiemcginty.com/new-tecumseth-real-estate

Thinking of Buying or Selling in Tottenham?

Call Jamie McGinty directly at 705-440-9440 or email jamie@jamiemcginty.com. For sellers, Jamie provides a market analysis based on recent comparable sales in Tottenham, not a generic estimate.